Articles on LZC, HVAC, PC & CAD too!

Pipe Corrosion - CUI


CUI on pipe by Homemicro.co.uk

Corrosion under Insulation (CUI) is any type of corrosion that occurs on the external surface of pipework due to the presence of moisture within or under the insulation system. A combination of moisture, a low level of oxygen, concentration of impurities (e.g. chloride) and temperature beneath the thermal insulation can lead to corrosion under insulation (CUI). The British Standard BS 5970, which covers the thermal insulation of pipework, details issues with corrosion under insulation and stress-corrosion cracking of brass alloys and austenitic alloy-steels (i.e., stainless steel 304 and 316).

This page does not address internal pipe corrosion.


The following content is available on this page - Click on a link to view

Causes of CUI Environmental Factors, pipe and insulation Materials, information for Specification, guidance on Installation and procedures for Maintenance.

How to Avoid CUI

Corrosion under insulation (CUI) can be prevented from occurring by following these basic guidelines on material selection and installation:

  • Environmental Factors: Determine environmental factors that will influence material specification. For example, are there services exposed to the external environment?
  • Materials: Select pipe, fittings, valves, protective coating, insulation, vapour barrier and outer-covering materials which are appropriate for the environment and use.
  • Specification: Ensure correct specification of insulation system materials (insulant, vapour barriers, cladding/jackets, mastics, etc.).
  • Standard Details: Identify and detail robust installation arrangements and finishing details which promote watertightness.
  • Installation: Inspect, monitor and confirm the installation materials and quality of the pipe and insulation installation is compliant with the specification and standard drawing details. Pay attention to final finishing detailing at all locations (joints, branches, valves, equipment connections, etc.) and fixings which are susceptible to water ingress.
  • Maintenance: Provide operating and maintenance instructions with requirements for the inspection and remedial repair of physical damage to insulation post-installation.


A message from a sponsor


Environmental Factors

A combination of moisture, a low level of oxygen, concentration of impurities (e.g. chloride) and temperature beneath the thermal insulation can lead to corrosion under insulation (CUI). The most important influences are temperature (operating and ambient) and water contact (in liquid or vapour state). CUI is any type of corrosion that occurs on pipework due to the presence of moisture within or under the insulation system. CUI can occur under any type of thermal insulation.

Corrosion under insulation is particularly aggressive where operating temperatures cause frequent condensation and re-evaporation of atmospheric moisture.

Water ingress from any external source such as rainfall, condensate from cold service equipment, steam discharge, process liquid spillage, wash-downs, etc. pose a risk for CUI if external finishes do not provide adequate water-tight protection.

Systems such as cold water, chilled water, refrigeration and cool air duct systems which all operate below ambient, are highly susceptible to the formation of condensation on their surfaces.


Formicary corrosion is a well-documented problem of external corrosion which can occur on copper pipework under phenolic foam insulation (formic acid attack from wet insulation).

Contaminants left during installation and residual flux used in joint assembly can contribute to corrosion. Some fluxes are more aggressive than others, but all fluxes should be considered corrosive to some extent. In coastal environments saltwater or salt laden air can cause aggressive corrosion.

Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) may occur in brass compression fittings or stainless steel components due to manufacturing defects or installation fault in environments with contaminants such as ammonia.

Materials

All metals are prone to corrosion. Some considerations are highlighted below.

Heavyweight steel tube has an inherent advantage with a thick wall that will take longer to corrode than thin-wall solutions. Lightweight thin-wall carbon pipe systems have less material in the pipes' structure, so the rate of corrosion that leads to failure can be rapid.

Austenitic stainless steel (to include 304 and 316) piping systems can suffer from stress corrosion cracking in the temperature range 50°C to 150°C. BS 5970 recommends the protection of stainless steel pipe surfaces, especially if the plant is likely to be heated to a temperature above 50°C. To avoid any issues with corrosion, stainless steel pipe must not be heated for bending.

Copper pipe systems are discouraged by the NHS in Scotland in Domestic Hot and Cold Water (DHCW) services in hospitals and other healthcare premises.

Brasses have a high susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking; copper, bronze and gun-metal are resistant to this type of corrosion. Over tightening brass fittings during installation can increase the risk of stress corrosion cracking. Brass fittings and valves should be wrapped with an effective moisture barrier tape such as butyl self-amalgamating tape.

As an alternative, gun-metal or copper fittings should be used in place of brass. Gun metal which is an alloy of [c.88%] copper, [8-10%] tin and zinc is resistant to stress corrosion cracking and dezincification.

Bronze is an alloy of copper and tin with good corrosion resistant. Bronze is a good choice for marine environments.


Plastic pipework systems are non-corrodible, however, internally the oxygen concentration will remain higher for longer and therefore corrodible materials elsewhere in the system will corrode at a high rate without suitable treatment.

Wood blocks should not be used as BS 5970 (2012) advises that they "should not be used for below ambient applications", they will expand in the presence of water and the thermal properties are poor when compared to thermal insulation blocks.


Specification

The specification of materials should identify:

  • Type of insulation, and insulation supports and their spacing.
  • Type and spacing of cladding supports.
  • Type of adhesives and sealants.
  • Method and type of secure fixing.
  • Methods to be adopted when applying material.
  • Insulation hanger details.
  • Insulation joint fabrication and fixing details.
  • Allowance made for expansion/contraction of plant under hot/cold cycles.
  • Provision for inspection and maintenance of the pipework system.


Standard Details

Thermal insulation fabrication details must be established and agreed before work commences. Application methods are detailed in BS 5970 and most thermal insulation manufacturers provide installation instructions which detail fabrication arrangements. These details will inform the installation requirements.


Installation Procedures

A poorly installed insulation system may ultimately let moisture or corrosive chemicals into the insulation and pipe surface, providing a catalyst for CUI. Attention should be given to preventing ingress of water.

Before installation the following preparation should be observed.

  • Leave sufficient clearance between each service to allow for the thickness of insulation.
  • Insulating materials should be kept dry in store and during erection.
  • Use only the correct bore insulated sections to suit the overall diameter of the pipework being insulated.
  • Pipework, fittings and valves should be stored in a dry environment.

Points to observe during installation:

  • Surfaces to be insulated should be cleaned thoroughly and be free of any foreign matter such as oil, grease, dirt, soldering flux, loose rust, scale, or any contaminants.
  • Pipes should be dry and free of frost.
  • Pipe fittings such as valve handles and binder test points, should extend beyond the insulation and cladding.
  • All joints must be close fitting and fully vapour sealed.

Application:

  • Tape all cut ends of the insulation with aluminium tape to form a complete seal.
  • The integrity of the vapour barrier must be continuous and maintained throughout the installation, particularly at exposed edges, valves, flanges, unions and equipment junctions.
  • Ensure the cladding forms a weather-tight seal.
  • Use a sealing compound to seal all protrusions through insulation and cladding.
  • Ensure cladding overlaps on all circumferential and longitudinal seams are sufficient.
  • Avoid linear joints on top of horizontal services distribution.
  • Install cladding overlaps to shed water (weatherwise - roof tile method).
  • Install horizontal flat cladding with a fall or slope to shed water and avoid pooling.
  • Lower section of vertical cladding should be installed first with upper section overlapping lower parts.
  • Ensure all insulation is secured in accordance with manufacturers' recommendations.
  • Install valves with the spindles placed horizontal or below.

Installation checks:

  • Inspection should be carried out after each stage of work has been completed and before the next stage has started.
  • Any work not of acceptable standard must be removed and replaced.
  • Ensure that the insulation is not wet or waterlogged.
  • Ensure the vapour barrier is continuous and is not damaged or ruptured prior or during the installation of the final outer cladding.
  • Ensure no adhesive tapes are applied to any pipes themselves, specifically at ends of pipe to 'neaten' or 'tidy' the appearance of the installation.
  • Ensure protective coatings are applied where required.

 


Maintenance

Maintaining thermal insulated pipework is essentially to identify and eliminate the occurrence of CUI. When installed the thermal insulation system must be arranged to permit repair and replacement of equipment and components in the pipework with minimal disturbance of the thermal insulation.

A routine should be adopted to carry out visual inspection, maintain and repair the following defects:

  • Condition of jackets and joints.
  • Presence of perforations, gaps, dents, etc.
  • Crushed or deformed insulation.
  • Evidence of ice, condensation, etc.
  • Missing insulation, including any removed and not reinstated.


Spare



Further Information

Corrosion

Loss of material from a component due to electrochemical reaction with its environmental.

Stainless Steel

304L (1.4307) and 316L (1.4404) grade of stainless steel has a lower carbon content and these grades are less susceptible to intergranular corrosion.

Three

Information coming soon


A message from a sponsor



 Pipe Corrosion id: hvac-15


2009-2024 All Rights Reserved - www.homemicro.co.uk    Based upon an original design by w3.css with a little help from Bootstrap & Pixaby / free images Pixaby free images